8 Unbelievable Coin Finds at Garage Sales: Thousands in Value!

Hey there, treasure hunters! Are you ready to hear some incredible stories of unexpected coin discoveries that turned ordinary garage sale visits into lucrative adventures? Join us as we delve into eight unbelievable coin finds that fetched thousands of dollars in value. Get ready to be amazed and inspired by these tales of numismatic luck!

1. Rare Bicentennial Quarter (Missing Mint Mark)

How much is a bicentennial quarter with no mint mark worth and has two  drumsticks? What is it worth? - Quora

Imagine stumbling upon a Bicentennial Quarter with a missing mint mark at a local garage sale. That’s exactly what happened to one lucky collector who scored big with a nearly priceless find. With a valuation reaching into the millions, this rare coin turned a routine garage sale visit into a life-changing windfall.

2. 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent

1943 1C Bronze, BN (Regular Strike) Lincoln Cent (Wheat Reverse) - PCGS  CoinFacts

In another astonishing discovery, a savvy shopper picked up a 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent for a mere fraction of its true worth. Minted in error during World War II, these copper beauties can fetch upwards of six figures at auction. Talk about a garage sale jackpot!

3. 1913 Liberty Head Nickel

1913 Liberty Head nickel - Wikipedia

One intrepid garage sale enthusiast struck numismatic gold when they uncovered a 1913 Liberty Head Nickel hiding among a box of miscellaneous items. With only five known specimens in existence, this rare coin is a true treasure worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

4. 1804 Draped Bust Silver Dollar

1804 $1 Restrike - Class II (Proof) Draped Bust Dollar - PCGS CoinFacts

Avid collectors know that you never know what you might find at a garage sale, and one lucky individual hit the jackpot when they unearthed an 1804 Draped Bust Silver Dollar. As one of the most sought-after coins in existence, this numismatic masterpiece can command prices in the millions.

5. 1933 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle

Only legal 1933 Saint-Gaudens gold $20 double eagle in June auction

Steeped in history and intrigue, the 1933 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle is a legendary coin with a value to match. When one collector stumbled upon this rare find at a garage sale, they knew they had struck numismatic gold. With values soaring into the millions, this discovery was nothing short of miraculous.

6. 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar

Flowing Hair Silver Dollar | US Silver Dollar | Austin Coins

As the first silver dollar struck by the United States Mint, the 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar is a numismatic marvel. When one lucky garage sale shopper uncovered this historic treasure, they couldn’t believe their luck. Valued at hundreds of thousands of dollars, this coin find was the stuff of dreams.

7. 1907 Ultra High Relief Double Eagle

1907 $20 Extremely High Relief Lettered Edge (Proof) St. Gaudens $20 - PCGS  CoinFacts

Designed by the renowned sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, the 1907 Ultra High Relief Double Eagle is a work of art in its own right. When one collector stumbled upon this rare coin at a garage sale, they knew they had found something special. With a value exceeding six figures, this discovery was truly extraordinary.

8. 1793 Chain Cent

1793 1C Chain, America, BN (Regular Strike) Flowing Hair Large Cent - PCGS  CoinFacts

Rounding out our list is the iconic 1793 Chain Cent, the first large cent struck by the United States Mint. When one lucky individual discovered this historic coin at a garage sale, they couldn’t believe their good fortune. Valued at tens of thousands of dollars, this unexpected find was a testament to the hidden treasures waiting to be uncovered at garage sales around the country.


From rare Bicentennial Quarters to historic Flowing Hair Dollars, these incredible coin finds prove that you never know what treasures you might unearth at a garage sale. So next time you’re out and about, keep your eyes peeled for that hidden gem—you never know what riches might be waiting just around the corner!


1. Can I really find valuable coins at garage sales?

Absolutely! Garage sales are treasure troves of hidden gems, and valuable coins are often overlooked among the clutter. With a keen eye and a bit of luck, you could uncover a numismatic treasure worth thousands of dollars.

2. How do I know if a coin is valuable?

Determining the value of a coin can be complex and often requires expertise. Factors such as rarity, condition, and demand among collectors all play a role in determining a coin’s worth. Consulting with a professional coin appraiser or doing thorough research online can help you assess the value of your coin finds.

3. Are there any other valuable items to look out for at garage sales?

Absolutely! In addition to coins, garage sales can yield a variety of valuable items, including antique furniture, vintage jewelry, and rare collectibles. Keeping an open mind and staying alert for unique finds can lead to exciting discoveries and unexpected treasures.

Leave a Comment